Owners access | Resort information and booking website unofficial
Ocean Colony Beach & Tennis Club Hotel Amagansett, Amagansett
256US$
Book with us
Up to 10% cheaper
than on Booking.com
Key details
About the Resort
2004 Montauk Highway,
Amagansett,
New York,
United States of America,
11930,
New York State
Ocean Colony Beach & Tennis Club features a private beach and outdoor pool, making it a suitable choice for families and couples. This 3-star Amagansett hotel offers air-conditioned rooms with kitchen facilities and private balconies.
Rooms & Amenities
Each room at Ocean Colony Beach & Tennis Club includes a flat-screen TV, coffee machine, and a private bathroom. Some rooms feature balconies with beautiful vistas, while certain accommodations provide a seating area to relax.
Leisure & Activities
Guests can enjoy tennis facilities onsite and take a dip in the outdoor pool. Nearby, explore local parks such as Hither Hills State Park and Napeague State Park for outdoor activities.
Services & Facilities
Ocean Colony Beach & Tennis Club offers free parking and complimentary Wi-Fi for guests. The 24-hour front desk provides assistance for any inquiries.
Location & Nearby Attractions
The hotel is located within walking distance to the beachfront and is a short drive from local attractions including Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course and the Victor D'Amico Institute of Art.
View all
Select your room type
The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals
Explore available ways to reach your dream destination
City Center
Amagansett
5.3
mi
Airports
Long Island MacArthur (ISP)
60.5
mi
Hartford-Brainard (HFD)
99.1
mi
Facilities
The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences
Spacious Rooms!
“The one-bedroom loft we stayed in was incredibly spacious and well-cared for, allowing us to relax comfortably throughout our trip.” view full review
Clean and Inviting
“The bathrooms were spotless and well-maintained, providing a serene space after a long day.” view full review
Great Pool Area
“The pool was very nice and well-kept, providing a perfect spot to unwind and soak up the sun.” view full review
Accommodating Layout
“The overall complex was designed in a way that offered easy accessibility, making it comfortable for all guests to navigate.” view full review
General
Non-smoking property
Free Wi-Fi
Free parking
Front desk
Guest Parking
Kitchen
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
Services
Laundry
Children
Game room
Spa & Leisure
Outdoor swimming pool
Room features
Free Wi-Fi in rooms
Sitting area
Bathroom
Free toiletries
Self-catering
Kitchen
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
Media
Flat-screen TV
Show more
Location
2004 Montauk Highway,
Amagansett,
New York,
United States of America,
11930,
New York State
Map view
2004 Montauk Highway,
Amagansett,
New York,
United States of America,
11930,
New York State
City landmarks
Beach
Napeague Beach
2700 ft
Parks
Hither Hills State Park
1.9
mi
Gallery
Victor D'Amico Institute of Art
4400 ft
Parks
Napeague State Park
1.5
mi
Island
Hicks Island
1.5
mi
Hither Hills West Overlook
2.3
mi
Parks
Theodore Roosevelt County Park
2.5
mi
Napeague Bay
2.7
mi
Indian House Ruins
2.7
mi
91 Napeague Harbor Rd
Walking Dunes
120.7
mi
Walking Dunes Trailhead
120.7
mi
Nearby
Montauk Point Lighthouse
600 ft
Restaurants
The Lobster Roll
900 ft
1980 Montauk Highway
Reviews and Ratings
Feedback from previous guests about their experience
60%
liked the resort and would come back again
Great beach access
Spacious rooms
Inadequate service
Misleading room descriptions
6.0/10
Guest rating
Rooms
5.4
Location
8.4
Service
5.0
Dining
5.0
Guest reviews
6.0/10
based on 5 reviews
3.5/5
based on 69 reviews
8.2
8.2/10 based on 97 reviews
#6 of 6 hotels in Amagansett based on Tripadvisor
Mark
United States of America,
February
2025
6.0/10
I had a mixed experience at Ocean Colony Beach and Tennis Club. The location is fantastic, just steps from the beach, and the pool area is nice. However, the room we stayed in fell short of expectations, feeling more outdated than advertised. The service was decent but marred by some miscommunication regarding our booking. Overall, it’s not a bad choice, but there are definitely better options for the price.
Rooms
5.0
The room was outdated and not what I expected; it had cleanliness issues including mold and pests. While it was advertised as a ‘lower ocean view’, my view was blocked, which was disappointing.
Service
6.0
Service was reasonable, but there were some issues with communication about room pricing that left a sour taste.
Location
9.0
The location is hard to beat, right on the beach and close to convenient shopping and food options.
Dining
5.0
There were limited dining options nearby, and food was only available after 11:30 A.M., which can be restrictive for early risers.
Facilities
7.0
The facilities were decent with a nice pool and tennis courts, but the lack of care in the room cleanliness detracted from the overall experience.
William
United States of America,
December
2024
7.2/10
I really enjoyed my stay at the resort, especially with the heated pool and the beach being only steps away from my room. The living space was nice and had an updated kitchen, but the bedroom felt a bit basic and the mattress could have been better. I did notice some noise from the room above, which was a downside. Overall, it was a great getaway for families or friends, but there were a few areas that could be improved.
Rooms
7.0
The living area was pleasant, and the kitchen was clean and modern, but the bedroom could use more amenities and better lighting.
Service
7.0
Check-in was smooth, and there were plenty of towels available, but the handling of the beach chair reservations could have been communicated better.
Location
9.0
The location is fantastic, just a short walk to the beach and nearby lunch spots. It's quiet and away from the crowds, which I loved.
Dining
5.0
There were limited dining options available on-site for brunch, which was a bit disappointing after 11:30 A.M.
Facilities
8.0
The heated pool was a highlight, and the outdoor deck provided ample seating, but updates could be made to the shower and overall room lighting.
Kenneth
United States of America,
October
2024
6.6/10
My stay was quite mixed. The location is fabulous, right on the beach and close to everything while still being away from the crowds. The rooms are spacious and well-kept, but I found them a bit dated and not worth the steep price. The service, however, left much to be desired, especially when it came to addressing our concerns about additional charges. Overall, it has its pros, but there are definitely areas that need improvement.
Rooms
7.0
The rooms are spacious and well-cared for, but they felt a bit dated despite renovations. The ocean view from our unit was misleading, and I felt misled regarding the room description.
Service
5.0
The service could improve significantly, as my concerns weren't taken seriously, and I felt talked down to when discussing additional charges.
Location
9.0
The location is excellent—right on the beach and just a short drive to Montauk's town, which was super convenient for us.
Dining
Facilities
Great beach access
Inadequate service
Terry
United States of America,
October
2024
5.0/10
We had a mixed experience at this resort. While the location is decent and the beach access is great, the rooms were misleadingly advertised and the customer service left a lot to be desired. Overall, I feel we didn't get the value for the price we paid, especially given the issues with cleanliness and the lack of response from management regarding our concerns.
Rooms
5.0
The room was described as a lower ocean view, but I couldn't see any ocean. There were also issues like mold and ants in the bathroom, which was quite disappointing.
Service
5.0
The service was lacking. The assistant manager was rude when I raised my concerns, and it felt like they didn't care about fixing the issues we encountered.
Location
7.0
The resort is conveniently close to the beach, but the view from our room was very misleading.
Dining
Facilities
6.0
Facilities like the pool and tennis courts were decent, but they didn't make up for the negative experience overall.
Fred
United States of America,
October
2024
6.4/10
We had a decent stay at the hotel, enjoying clean rooms and a great location near the beach. However, the price seemed quite steep, and navigating various charges was frustrating. While the balcony offered some nice views, it fell short of our expectations regarding the advertised ocean views. Overall, it was a mixed experience, with positives and negatives balancing out.
Rooms
7.0
The room was clean and well-stocked, but the decor felt a bit outdated. The mattress was hard, yet manageable for our stay.
Service
6.0
Service was mixed; while some staff were friendly and accommodating, we felt confused by additional charges and miscommunication regarding our unit options.
Location
8.0
The location was ideal for beach access, just a short walk away. It was convenient for exploring the area, though the stairs to our unit were a workout.
Dining
5.0
We didn’t dine extensively at the hotel, but it was nice having options nearby. Breakfast service could use improvement.
Facilities
6.0
The facilities were decent, but improvements are needed in communication regarding amenities. The beach chair reservation system through an app was confusing.
Brahma Blue Resort
Silver Rapids Lodge & Campground
Domes Miramare, A Luxury Collection Resort, Corfu - Adults Only
Wyndham Gramado Termas Resort & Spa
Cherokee Mountain Log Cabins
Pavilion Samui Villas And Resort - Sha Extra Plus
Hotel Santa Fe Los Cabos By Villa Group
Prestige Rocky Mountain Resort Cranbrook, Worldhotels Crafted
Sugar Bay Resort And Spa
Thunderbird Resorts - Rizal
Ocean Time
Four Points By Sheraton Palawan Puerto Princesa